بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَٰنِ الرَّحِيمِ
6 Jumada al-Akhirah 1448 AH
Fajr: 04:36 Dhuhr: 11:58 Asr: 15:12 Maghrib: 18:02 Isha: 19:11
☪
فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ
Quranic Studies & Exegesis

Examining the Historical Realities: Why the Claim That the Quran Copied the Bible Fails Under Scrutiny

By: Muslim • Nov 17, 2026 • 5 min read

For centuries, a recurring allegation leveled by various critics and Christian polemicists has been that the Quran is nothing more than a derivative work—a mere copy of the Bible. According to this narrative, Prophet Muhammad simply plagiarized the contents of his holy book from the pages of the Old and New Testaments. While it is an established historical fact that the revelation of the Quran came chronologically after the existence of the Bible, and that both texts cover significant common ground regarding shared prophets, moral frameworks, and historical narratives, the conclusion drawn by these critics—that the Prophet systematically studied the Bible to fabricate the Quran—is entirely untenable and collapses under serious historical and textual scrutiny.

To understand why this plagiarism hypothesis fails, historians and scholars point to several fundamental chronological, linguistic, and biographical realities that make such a theory impossible.

The Absence of an Arabic Bible in Seventh-Century Arabia

The primary obstacle to the theory that Prophet Muhammad copied from the Bible lies in a simple linguistic reality: during the Prophet’s lifetime, there was no Arabic translation of the Bible available in the Arabian Peninsula.

This historical fact is well-documented by biblical scholars. Ernst Würthwein, in his authoritative work The Text of the Old Testament, sheds light on the timeline of Arabic translations of scripture. He notes that with the rapid expansion and victory of Islam, the use of Arabic spread widely across the region. For Jews and Christians living in the newly conquered lands, Arabic gradually became the language of daily life. This demographic and linguistic shift eventually generated a pressing need for Arabic versions of the scriptures.

As Würthwein explains, this need was met by a number of versions that were largely independent and concerned primarily with interpretation. Consequently, the earliest translations of the Hebrew Bible into Arabic only began to appear after the advent of Islam. Historical records confirm that the oldest dated manuscript of the Old Testament in Arabic dates no earlier than the first half of the ninth century—centuries after the passing of Prophet Muhammad.

The situation regarding the New Testament mirrors that of the Hebrew Bible. Sidney H. Griffith, a prominent scholar who has conducted extensive research into the early appearance of Arabic and the translation history of the New Testament, notes a similar timeline. According to Griffith, the oldest dated manuscript containing the Gospels in Arabic is Sinai Arabic MS 72. In this historic document, the text of the four canonical Gospels is structured according to the lessons of the temporal cycle of the Greek liturgical calendar of the Jerusalem Church. A colophon within the manuscript informs historians that it was written by Stephen of Ramleh in the year 284 of the Arab calendar, which corresponds to the year 897 CE.

6 Reasons Qur’an Cannot Be a Copy of Bible

When juxtaposed with the timeline of Prophet Muhammad—who passed away in the first half of the seventh century, specifically in the year 632 CE—the chronological impossibility of the plagiarism claim becomes starkly evident. The Prophet lived and completed his mission more than two and a half centuries before the earliest known complete Arabic Bible manuscripts were even compiled. Without accessible Arabic translations of the biblical texts in circulation during his lifetime in Makkah or Madinah, the premise that he read, studied, and copied from them is historically baseless.

The Reality of the Unlettered Prophet

Beyond the linguistic and chronological barriers, the theory of plagiarism runs into a profound biographical contradiction: Prophet Muhammad was famously unlettered, a status widely recognized and documented by both his followers and his harshest contemporary critics.

To accept the notion that the Prophet authored the Quran by synthesizing various theological sources, one would have to assume that an unlettered man residing in the isolated environment of pre-Islamic Arabia possessed the ability to comprehensively study, analyze, and assimilate a vast array of complex traditions. These allegedly included Christian, Jewish, Zoroastrian, Hanif, and ancient indigenous Arab beliefs, all before synthesizing them into the eloquent and cohesive structure of the Quran.

Such a scenario is not only historically ironic but entirely unsupported by the historical record. The illiteracy of Prophet Muhammad was a matter of common knowledge among the people of his time, acknowledged even by the pagan adversaries of Islam 1,400 years ago. Notably, throughout the intense ideological struggles and debates between the early Muslims and the Quraysh leaders in Makkah, there is no historical record or narration suggesting that the pagan Arabs ever accused Muhammad of pretending to be illiterate while secretly possessing the ability to read and write. Had such a contradiction existed, his contemporary opponents, who closely scrutinized his every action, would have weaponized it immediately.

This reality of the Prophet’s unlettered status is also addressed directly within the text of the Quran itself. In Surah Al-Ankabut, verses 48 through 49, the text challenges the skeptics directly, stating: "And thou wast not [able] to recite a Book before this [Book came] nor art thou [able] to transcribe it with thy right hand: in that case indeed would the talkers of vanities have doubted. Nay here are signs self-evident in the hearts of those endowed with knowledge: and none but the unjust reject Our signs."

These verses emphasize that the origin of the text transcends human authorship, pointing to internal consistency and self-evident spiritual truths that resonated with those possessing discernment. Ultimately, when measured against the absence of contemporary Arabic biblical texts, the chronological gap before the first ninth-century translations, and the universally acknowledged illiteracy of the Prophet, the allegation that the Quran is a mere copy of the Bible collapses under the weight of historical facts.

☪
Author / Editorial Team:

Muslim